Observation/Field Notes
Tanner is a first grade boy on a low math level. He worked slowly on his worksheets, counting on his finger often. He missed several problems on his worksheet.
Haylie is a first grade girl on a high level in math. She worked quietly and by herself when doing her worksheet. She did most of the problems in her head. She got all of the answers right on her worksheet except for the time problem. She finished quickly so the teacher assigned her extra problems that are on a second grade level and involve more problem solving skills.
Interview with Haylie
1. adding, subtracting, money, and inches
2. yes, likes doing $$ problems
4. is important
5. counts the dogs and cats @ her house
6. money b/c she can count it
7. subtraction b/c it hard
8. adding
9. subtraction
10. ask friend of teacher
11. answers and words
12. is a girl, just b/c
Interview with Tanner
1. adding and subtraction
2. yes, likes to add
4. yes it has
5. no
6. adding b/c is fun and easy
7. finding the most b/c its hard
8. adding
9. money problems
10. ask teacher
11. nothing
12. is a boy b/c girls don’t do that (he
also said that he wouldn’t want to do that)
Group Observations
1. Kids just listed things that they do in
math class.
2. Boys seem to not like math because takes
too long and has too many directions. Girls seem to like math because it
is fun.
4. Math is important because you learn
from it.
5. They consider most math outside of school
as just homework, although
some counted and measured stuff.
6. Favorite of Kindergartners was sorting
while first graders seem to like a little bit of everything.
7. Least favorite varied too a little bit
of everything.
8. Easiest almost always was their favorite.
9. Hardiest almost always was their least
favorite.
10. Most would ask teacher or someone sitting
near them if they had a problem in school with math.
11. Answers varied from nothing to words
and answers.
12. All girls drew female mathematicians
and all boys drew boy mathematicians.
Reflection
From my interviews and our group discussion
I would say that the responses that we received do fit with what I have
read in the developmental studies for Kindergarten and First Grade. The
kindergartners displayed the following characteristics of their age: sorting
objects by size with several of them saying that was their favorite activity,
drawing pictures that represent people because all drew a picture of what
they thought a mathematician looked like, and recognizing categories which
would go along with sorting. The First Graders showed these characteristics
of their age: ability to only focus on one problem at a time, reversing
printed numbers(especially 3’s) and letters, and starting to understand
time and days of week with a time problem on math worksheets and weeks
during calendar time.
One thing that I learned from this
assessment is that children enjoy what they are good at and what is easy
for them and dislike what is hard for them and what they do not see as
fun. This furthered what we discussed in class when we did out Math Life
projects. Even teens and adults like what they are good at and do not enjoy
what they aren’t good at.
The students did not seem to mind
being asked the questions as long as the session was kept short. I told
both kids that I needed help with my homework and they were very happy
to help me by answering the questions. I did not let the students know
that know that I was observing them doing their math worksheets.
I knew before I interviewed Haylie
and Tanner I knew which was on high and low level. I think that this may
not have been the best idea because it could have biased me when I was
observing and interviewing.
I was intrigued that the girl thought
that mathematicians had to be female and the boy thought that they had
to be boys because girls don’t do that sort of thing. This rang true with
the students that my group members interviewed too. Why is it that they
see the mathematician as the same sex as they are?
I am not sure how practical it would
be for a teacher to interview all of her students using a specific set
of questions to find out their attitudes about math. I can see how the
knowledge about which parts of math students like the best and dislike
the most would be helpful. Especially believing that what they dislike
the most is what they have the hardest time with. Then you would know what
areas you need to focus on with which kids.
I enjoyed talking to a couple of the
students and hearing what they had to say about Math and the other random
stories they told in between answering my questions.