Discussion Director
Example Page
2 Prediction:
-
Page 15: Esperanza's Abuelita
told her, "Do not be afraid to start over." Predict how this comment
may be important later in the story.
I think this will be important
if something bad happens to Esperanza's family and she is forced to begin
her life over again.
-
Page 22: How do you think the
loss of Esperanza's father will affect her family?
I think the loss of Esperanza's
father will affect her family in that her family may loose the vineyards
and their money. If this happens they will have to adapt to being
poor.
2 Opinion:
-
Page 17: Esperanza says one day
she wishes to marry Miguel, and her father says that one day she will feel
differently about that comment? Why do you think Esperanza's father
believes Esperanza will feel differently about Miguel when she gets older?
I think Esperanza's father said
this because he knows that society will train Esperanza to believe that
she is better than Miguel. Society will warp Esperanza's outlook
like this because her family is wealthy and Miguel's family is not.
-
Page 18: why do you think that
Miguel stopped talking to Esperanza ?
I think Miguel stopped talking
to Esperanza because his feelings about her were more than those of a mere
friend, and Esperanza hurt his feelings by saying they could never be more
than friends due to his social status.
1 Fact:
-
Pages 7-8: In the Hispanic culture
what is the importance of a girl's 15 birthday?
In the Hispanic culture a girl's
15 birthday symbolizes her coming of age. Girls are presented on
their 15 birthday and are allowed to be courted, dated, marry, and become
the head of their households.
Return to
Lesson